| Sport: Baseball | Year: 2021 |
|
Division: American |
FIRST TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Danielle Cifu | Millburn |
| 2. Anthony Anzaldi | Montclair |
| 3. Lou Raffaelli | Nutley |
| 4. Nico Ong | Bloomfield |
| 5. Tyler Sorrentino | West Essex |
| 6. Brett Janifer | Montclair |
| 7. Vincent Panzarino | West Essex |
| 8. David Cotugno | Livingston |
| 9. Sean Brown | Montclair |
| 10. Chris Maldonado | Seton Hall Prep |
| 11. Ryan Sprock | Seton Hall Prep |
| 12. Andre Dean | Bloomfield |
| 13. Jeremy Sacks | Montclair |
SECOND TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. John Cerwinski | Seton Hall Prep |
| 2. Tyler Markman | West Essex |
| 3. Dillion Jennings | Bloomfield |
| 4. Amar Francis | Montclair |
| 5. Steven Echavarria | Millburn |
| 6. Chris Battista | Livingston |
| 7. Karson Harcourt | Seton Hall Prep |
| 8. Melvin Matias | Montclair |
| 9. Brandon Piacenza | Bloomfield |
| 10. Justin Waack | West Essex |
| 11. Joe Delanzo | Nutley |
| 12. Liam Hempstead | Bloomfield |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Alex Wilson | Millburn |
| 2. Robert Schneider | Millburn |
| 3. Jude Clough | West Essex |
| 4. Stephen Zerance | West Essex |
| 5. Nick Murray | Livingston |
| 6. Robert Sayle | Livingston |
| 7. Christopher Sanchez | Bloomfield |
| 8. Charles Abplanalp | Bloomfield |
| 9. Dylan Santos | Nutley |
| 10. Jake Walsh | Nutley |
| 11. Jack Burke | Montclair |
| 12. Nick Levine | Montclair |
| 13. Sam Nomura | Seton Hall Prep |
| 14. Andrew Fernandez | Seton Hall Prep |