| First Team | Weight | School |
| Dom Tafuri | 106 | Cedar Grove |
| Merlin Senat | 113 | Orange |
| Mike Policarpio | 120 | Millburn |
| Josh Dabon | 126 | Belleville |
| CJ Love | 132 | Columbia |
| Carl Banks | 138 | Irvington |
| David Guerra | 145 | Belleville |
| Billy Messinger | 152 | Cedar Grove |
| Hakim Fennell | 160 | Belleville |
| Geraldino Raymond | 170 | Orange |
| Liam Haggerty | 182 | Millburn |
| Nick Bianco | 195 | Cedar Grove |
| Edwin Lewis | 220 | Irvington |
| Justin Evans | HWT | Irvington |
| Nick Coletta | open | Cedar Grove |
| Gabriel Tato | open | East Side |
| Antonio Cuffari | open | Cedar Grove |
|
2nd Team |
Weight | School |
| Ross Berkowitz | 106 | Montclair |
| Jesse Pepper | 113 | Montclair |
| Jayson Turner | 120 | Irvington |
| Malachi Purkett | 126 | Irvington |
| Brandon Vitale | 132 | Belleville |
| Zakai Mack | 138 | Montclair |
| Francesco Merolli | 145 | Millburn |
| Sam Cohen | 152 | Millburn |
| Nick Catalano | 160 | Cedar Grove |
| Anthony D’Alessio | 170 | Cedar Grove |
| Isaiah Augustin | 182 | Irvington |
| Lensley Therlonge | 195 | Irvington |
| Jostin Gomez | 220 | Belleville |
| David Peterkin | HWT | Belleville |
| Lawrence Mendoza | open | Belleville |
| Zalyn Smith | open | Irvington |
| Sabastien Fortune | open | Montclair |
Honorable Mention
| School | Name |
| Cedar Grove | Sebastiano Locascio |
| Millburn | Joey Waldman |
| Irvington | Zaire Younger |
| Belleville | Malvin Gavarrete |
| Orange | Alfredo Sanchez |
| Montclair | Josh Lozano |
| East Side | Jose Martinez |
| Columbia | Max Moore |