| First Team | Weight | School |
| Joseph Sciarrone | 106 | Seton Hall |
| Ricardo Caamano | 113 | Caldwell |
| Damianlee Torres | 120 | West Orange |
| Larry Melchionda | 126 | Seton Hall |
| CarsonBarry | 132 | West Essex |
| Darren Jones | 138 | West Essex |
| Cole Carroll | 145 | Seton Hall |
| Alex Jones | 152 | West Essex |
| Jack Wilt | 160 | Seton Hall |
| Zach Merlino | 170 | Seton Hall |
| Adonis May | 182 | West Orange |
| Michael Massa | 195 | Seton Hall |
| Drew Mitzak | 220 | Seton Hall |
| Bardyl Gashi | HWT | West Essex |
| Sam Carsillo | open | West Essex |
| Agostino Petrillo | open | Livingston |
| Pete Haverick | open | Nutley |
| 2nd Team | Weight | School |
| Aidan Carmody | 106 | Livingston |
| Michael Pescatore | 113 | West Essex |
| Gabriel Jimenez | 120 | Seton Hall |
| Ricky Cassidy | 126 | West Essex |
| Dean Palmer | 132 | Verona |
| Connor Decker | 138 | Seton Hall |
| Jacob Gonzalez | 145 | Nutley |
| Max Lee | 152 | Livingston |
| Sal Mainiero | 160 | Nutley |
| Stratos Kantanas | 170 | Livingston |
| Zachary Andruchavitz | 182 | Bloomfield |
| John Casale | 195 | Caldwell |
| Ben Rivera | 220 | Caldwell |
| Billy Searle | HWT | Nutley |
| Shawn Quirk | open | Livingston |
| D’Isaiah Larrea | open | Bloomfield |
| Dean Musialowicz | open | Seton Hall |
| Jack Askling | open | Caldwell |
Honorable Mention
| School | Name |
| Seton Hall | Aidan Cunningham |
| Seton Hall | AJ Hinton |
| West Essex | Joey Macrino |
| West Essex | Matt Zaccaria |
| Caldwell | Luke Schaffer |
| Caldwell | Max Ruiz |
| Livingston | Anthony Newman |
| Livingston | Zach Vera |
| Bloomfield | Jeffery Diaz |
| Bloomfield | Dillon Jennings |
| West Orange | Danny Pereria |
| West Orange | Michael Charles |
| Verona | Sam Zamloot |
| Verona | Derek Bernardino |
| Nutley | Dan Jennings |
| Nutley | Anthony Haines |