SPORT: Wrestling – 2018-2019
AMERICAN DIVISION FIRST TEAM
| Name | Weight | School |
| Dom Tafuri | 106 | Cedar Grove |
| Rick Cassidy | 113 | West Essex |
| Larry Melchionda | 120 | Seton Hall |
| James Benjamin | 126 | West Orange |
| Mike Ruane | 132 | West Essex |
| Cole Carroll | 138 | Seton Hall |
| Jon Bartley | 145 | West Essex |
| Jack Wilt | 152 | Seton Hall |
| Colin Morgan | 160 | West Orange |
| Mike Massa | 170 | Seton Hall |
| Luke Dignazio | 182 | West Essex |
| Austin Paris | 195 | Livingston |
| Nick Boffa | 220 | Livingston |
| Bardhyl Gashi | HWT | West Essex |
| Nico Diakides | open | Seton Hall |
| Carl Banks | open | Irvington |
| Nashawn Brooks | open | Irvington |
| Connor Decker | open | Seton Hall |
AMERICAN DIVISION SECOND TEAM
| Name | Weight | School |
| Ricardo Caamano | 106 | Caldwell |
| Anthony Fabrazzo | 113 | Cedar Grove |
| Antonio Cuffari | 120 | Cedar Grove |
| Agostino Petrillo | 126 | Livingston |
| Darren Jones | 132 | West Essex |
| Edgar Moreno | 138 | West Orange |
| Will Dye | 145 | Cedar Grove |
| Sal Mainiero | 152 | Nutley |
| AS Hinton | 160 | Seton Hall |
| Nick Riggio | 170 | Verona |
| Zach Merlino | 182 | Seton Hall |
| Andrew Mitzak | 195 | Seton Hall |
| Cade Byrne | 220 | Verona |
| Billy Searle | HWT | Nutley |
| Carson Barry | open | West Essex |
| Frank Riggio | open | Verona |
| Dan Jennings | open | Nutley |
| Adonis May | open | West Orange |
American Honorable Mention
| Name | School |
| Jacob Gonzalez | Nutley |
| Peter Haverick | Nutley |
| Nick Coletta | Cedar Grove |
| William Messinger | Cedar Grove |
| Peter Kenny | West Essex |
| Michael Pescatore | West Essex |
| Mike Garcia | Verona |
| Dean Palmer | Verona |
| Sean Neary | Livingston |
| Max Lee | Livingston |
| Gabe Jimenez | Seton Hall |
| Joe Sciarrone | Seton Hall |
| Nunzio Castaldo | West Orange |
| Andrew Amogaw | West Orange |
| Jamal Joseph | Irvington |
| Edwin Louis | Irvington |