American Division
FIRST TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Griffin Westin | Seton Hall Prep |
| 2. Cole Kirst | Seton Hall Prep |
| 3. Jason Scher | Livingston |
| 4. Brian Russo | Livingston |
| 5. Cameron Fiore | Seton Hall Prep |
| 6. Jack Sarson | Seton Hall Prep |
| 7. Thomas Colucci | Seton Hall Prep |
| 8. James Miller | Caldwell |
| 9. Pat Theobald | Caldwell |
| 10. Anthony Costigan | Caldwell |
| 11. Kyle Rochester | Glen Ridge |
| 12. Tyler Strong | Glen Ridge |
| 13. Matt Fermo | Caldwell |
| 14. Will Shiffenhaus | Montclair |
| 15. Tommy Drago | West Essex |
SECOND TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Ryan Valese | Livingston |
| 2. Eddie O’Donnell | Livingston |
| 3. John Farrell | Seton Hall Prep |
| 4. Kyle Stephenson | Seton Hall Prep |
| 5. Connell Kumar | Seton Hall Prep |
| 6. Ege Zybek | Glen Ridge |
| 7. Jackson Crutchfield | Glen Ridge |
| 8. Finn Jensen | Montclair |
| 9. Ashton Smith | Montclair |
| 10. Brendan Lackey | Columbia |
| 11. Cullen Wolff | Seton Hall Prep |
| 12. Patrick Delehanty | West Essex |
| 13. Dylan Murphy | West Essex |
| 14. Kyle Ross | Caldwell |
| 15. Matt DiBlasio | Caldwell |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Kyle Kobylinski | Glen Ridge |
| 2. Thomas Pescator | West Essex |
| 3. Pierson Rambusch | Seton Hall Prep |
| 4. Connor Hapward | Caldwell |
| 5. Luke Nardone | Livingston |
| 6. Manny Deutsch | Columbia |
| 7. Jordan Painter | Montclair |