| Division: American |
FIRST TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Kevin Czapelski | Millburn |
| 2. Brendan Shamieh | Seton Hall Prep |
| 3. Mike Gibbons | Newark Academy |
| 4. Matt O’Neill | Seton Hall Prep |
| 5. Tyler Zuppa | Livingston |
| 6. Makhi Booker | Montclair |
| 7. Anthony Giachin | Newark Academy |
| 8. Alex Baratta | Seton Hall Prep |
| 9. Omari Beaubien | Livingston |
| 10. Anthony Condito | Nutley |
| 11. Tyler Brosius | Seton Hall Prep |
| 12. Anthony Frascati | Bloomfield |
| 13. Max Jacobs | Millburn |
SECOND TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Eric Kaufman | Seton Hall Prep |
| 2. Jordan Guglielmino | Bloomfield |
| 3. Jason Aktas | Bloomfield |
| 4. Max Birner | Millburn |
| 5. George Dittrich | Bloomfield |
| 6. Steve Basantes | Belleville |
| 7. Patrick O’Hare | Seton Hall Prep |
| 8. Austin Miles | Livingston |
| 9. Nick Starpoli | Montclair |
| 10. Dan Carter | Bloomfield |
| 11. Rich Schiekofer | Millburn |
| 12. Dylan Walicky | Belleville |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Mark Silvestri | Livingston |
| 2. Shane McLaughlin | Livingston |
| 3. Ryan McSherry | Seton Hall Prep |
| 4. Carter Chase | Seton Hall Prep |
| 5. Dustin Walicky | Belleville |
| 6. Quazyre Smith | Belleville |
| 7. Nick Martino | Newark Academy |
| 8. Jason Cohen | Newark Academy |
| 9. Matt McGoey | Montclair |
| 10. Carey Nadison | Montclair |
| 11. Ryan Boggio | Caldwell |
| 12. Steve Puzzo | Caldwell |
| 13. Dionisios Bello | Bloomfield |
| 14. Josh Cruz | Bloomfield |
| 15. Angelo Gaeta | Nutley |
| 16. Sean Rodriguez | Nutley |
| 17. John Serruto | Millburn |
| 18. Michael Garawitz | Millburn |