| Sport: Softball | Year: 2021 |
|
Division: AMERICAN |
FIRST TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Sophia Kiseloski | MSDA |
| 2. Fallyn Stoeckel | Nutley |
| 3. Sophia Mount | Livingston |
| 4. Melanie Naeris | Verona |
| 5. Katie Peterson | Cedar Grove |
| 6. Faith Reed | Verona |
| 7. Olivia Bibbo | MSDA |
| 8. Lori O’Connor | Nutley |
| 9. Sydney Rosenkranz | MSDA |
| 10. Alexa Raphael | MSDA |
| 11. Nathalia Dilanni | Livingston |
| 12. Jacqueline Loudon | Verona |
| 13. Sydney Waldon | Columbia |
SECOND TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Grace Perez | MSDA |
| 2. Caitlin Mullen | Livingston |
| 3. Gianna Stern | MSDA |
| 4. Guilia Wilson | Livingston |
| 5. Samantha Costigan | Verona |
| 6. Carlie Goldstein | Verona |
| 7. Haley Meierhofer | Livingston |
| 8. Sydney Hess | Nutley |
| 9. Julie Guerriero | West Essex |
| 10. Talia Recenello | Cedar Grove |
| 11. Lia Demaio | Nutley |
| 12. Deja Robinson | Livingston |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Alex Cruz | MSDA |
| 2. Olivia Sasfai | MSDA |
| 3. Paige Scheid | Cedar Grove |
| 4. Keanna Grande | Cedar Grove |
| 5. Emily Hunter | Livingston |
| 6. Hailey Reuter | Livingston |
| 7. Sam Stein | Columbia |
| 8. Ellie Martin | Columbia |
| 9. Courtney Turanick | West Essex |
| 10. Julianna Tornatore | West Essex |
| 11. Mia DiPiano | Nutley |
| 12. Julia Ciccone | Nutley |
| 13. Jessica Loudon | Verona |
| 14. Megan Meehan | Verona |