FIRST TEAM
| Name | Weight | School |
| Izaiha Gonzalez | 106 | Newark Collegiate |
| Adin Fastov | 113 | Newark Academy |
| Michael Marcus | 120 | Newark Academy |
| Seth Levin | 126 | Newark Academy |
| Jesse Samuelson | 132 | Glen Ridge |
| Johnathan Liang | 138 | Newark Academy |
| Ryder Smith | 145 | Glen Ridge |
| Alec Lewis | 152 | East Orange |
| Dominik Tasse | 160 | Newark Academy |
| William Hales | 170 | Newark Academy |
| James Mc Carren | 182 | Glen Ridge |
| Dean Geraci | 195 | Glen Ridge |
| Jalen Washington | 220 | Newark Collegiate |
| Tyree Reeves | 285 | Newark Collegiate |
| 2nd Team | Weight | School |
| Garrick Fuller | 106 | |
| Adrian Kim | 113 | |
| Andres Velazquez | 120 | |
| Marcus Southerland | 126 | |
| Elio Escobar | 132 | |
| Noel Lott | 138 | |
| Eon Godfrey | 145 | |
| Goodness OKoro | 152 | |
| Christian White | 160 | |
| Iain Shaw | 170 | |
| Stephen Nichols | 182 | |
| Yusef Henrey | 195 | |
| David Afolabi | 220 | |
| Quawee Shubrick-Felder | HWT |