| Division: American |
FIRST TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Shannon Bertscha | West Essex High School |
| 2. Bunny James | West Essex High School |
| 3. Skyler Sinsom | West Essex High School |
| 4. Erica Rinsky | West Essex High School |
| 5. Lindsey Ewertson | Montclair High School |
| 6. Julia Albert | Montclair High School |
| 7. Amanda Romano | Montclair High School |
| 8. Tess Howland | Glen Ridge High School |
| 9. Galen Lew | Glen Ridge High School |
| 10. Jackie Brozyna | Verona High School |
| 11. Amanda Maguire | Verona High School |
| 12. Samantha Gargiulo | Caldwell High School |
| 13. Lizzy Cimilluca | West Essex High School |
| 14. Colleen Grady | Glen Ridge High School |
| 15. Dana Pena | Verona High School |
SECOND TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Jordyn Thies | West Essex High School |
| 2. Rachel Cecere | West Essex High School |
| 3. Sabrina Saccente | West Essex High School |
| 4. Mia Oyama | West Essex High School |
| 5. Maggie Bigelow | Montclair High School |
| 6. Jillian Jennings | Montclair High School |
| 7. Antonia Kaz | Montclair High School |
| 8. Maddie Schmitt | Glen Ridge High School |
| 9. Merritt Davie | Glen Ridge High School |
| 10. Julia Tole | Verona High School |
| 11. Maggie Ashley | Verona High School |
| 12. Grace Conlon | Caldwell High School |
| 13. Jessica Bracamonte | Caldwell High School |
| 14. Juliann Lisovicz | Glen Ridge High School |
| 15. Rebecca Van Siclen | Montclair High School |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Grace O’Grady | Glen Ridge High School |
| 2. Cole McConnachie | Verona High School |
| 3. Brittany Costigan | Caldwell High School |
| 4. Nora Giordano | Montclair High School |
| 5. Gabby Girardi | West Essex High School |
| Division: Liberty |
FIRST TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Olivia Shevrin | Livingston High School |
| 2. Tatum Peacock | Livingston High School |
| 3. Alison Tortora | Millburn High School |
| 4. Caroline Shim | Millburn High School |
| 5. Ryan Steffen | Millburn High School |
| 6. Kim McGrath | Newark Academy |
| 7. Paige Kolek | Newark Academy |
| 8. Maria Bio | Mt St Dominic |
| 9. Quinn Dunnigan | Mt St Dominic |
| 10. Erin Duca | MKA |
| 11. Rachel Hegarty | MKA |
| 12. Annie Wallace | MKA |
| 13. Delaney Prenavost | Columbia High School |
| 14. Jasmine West | Columbia High School |
| 15. Kate O’Connell | Columbia High School |
SECOND TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Madeline DeLamielleure | Newark Academy |
| 2. Megan McCough | Newark Academy |
| 3. Madeline Christmann | Newark Academy |
| 4. Meghan Herbert | Mt St Dominic |
| 5. Brie Krug | Mt St Dominic |
| 6. Katherina DeMaio | Mt St Dominic |
| 7. Kira Dilley | Columbia High School |
| 8. Mae Ertl | Columbia High School |
| 9. Kaitlin Homberg | Livingston High School |
| 10. Kayla Francione | Livingston High School |
| 11. Monty Nelson | MKA |
| 12. Shannon Raff | MKA |
| 13. Samantha Pai | MKA |
| 14. Julia Draper | Millburn High School |
| 15. Ashley Donaldson | Millburn High School |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Amaya Lopez-Silvero | Newark Academy |
| 2. Finley Kemp | Columbia High School |
| 3. Amanda D’Alessandro | MKA |
| 4. Elizabeth Rovit | Millburn High School |
| 5. Emily Waldenberg | Livingston High School |
| 6. Maeve Naughton | Mt St Dominic |