Offense, 1st Team
| Name | School |
| Willie Barr, RB | Irvington |
| Salaam Rogers, OL | Irvington |
| Jyvon Brown, QB | Irvington |
| Craig Merkle, RB | Nutley |
| Rob Mellilo, QB | Nutley |
| Joe Iorio, C | Nutley |
| John Mannion, RB | Caldwell |
| Ian Davidson, C | Caldwell |
| Carl Watson, RB | Weequahic |
| Shafee Harris, WR | Weequahic |
| Jimmy Martinez, QB | Columbia |
| Matt Gibbon, QB | Livingston |
| Dyvenot Beublac, TE | Irvington |
| Kevin Davis, OT | Nutley |
Defense, 1st Team
| Garland Barham, DL | Irvington |
| Willens Estime, DE | Irvington |
| Deenell Fulton, LB | Irvington |
| Derrick Rivera, S | Irvington |
| Peter Russo, S | Nutley |
| Frank Malanga, LB | Nutley |
| Austin Brendel, DE | Nutley |
| Kevin Goudie, DB | Nutley |
| Jakim Wood, LB | Weequahic |
| Taj Jones, S | Weequahic |
| Nolan Smith, LB | Caldwell |
| Tom Guiliano, LB | Caldwell |
| Christian Paul-Pierre, LB | Columbia |
| Zach Marini, DE | Livingston |
Offense, 2nd Team
| Ghandi Romain, RB | Irvington |
| Alex Bruney, OL | Irvington |
| Dejah Grier, OL | Irvington |
| Jason Hoffman, TE | Nutley |
| Devin White, OG | Nutley |
| Anthony Condito, WR | Nutley |
| Jacob Charpentier, OT | Caldwell |
| Joseph Testa, OT | Caldwell |
| Stephen Puzo, WR | Caldwell |
| Richard Rubin, C | Weequahic |
| Tyman Sampson, QB | Weequahic |
| Amir Marsette, WR | Weequahic |
| Kiambu Jones, RB | Columbia |
| Mark Silvestri, WR | Livingston |
Defense, 2nd Team
| Lamar Frazier, DL | Irvington |
| Kiquan Durham, DE | Irvington |
| Dominick Caldwell, LB | Irvington |
| Devin Merritt, LB | Nutley |
| Andrew Aiello, S | Nutley |
| Jesse DeFuria, DT | Nutley |
| Aulon Haziri, DL | Caldwell |
| AJ Curtiss, DB | Caldwell |
| James Miller, DB | Caldwell |
| Cristian Roper, LB | Weequahic |
| Mamadee Konneh, DL | Weequahic |
| Evander Jackson, LB | Columbia |
| Jonny Schrieber, LB | Livingston |
| Omar Harris, DB | Weequahic |
Honorable Mention
| Malik Hazel, LB | Irvington |
| Tyrone Daniels, RB | Irvington |
| August Mustardo, OT | Nutley |
| Matt Gentiempo, K | Nutley |
| Dean Pierone, G | Caldwell |
| Darian Andreky, OT | Caldwell |
| Abdul Sills, OL | Weequahic |
| Derrick Jones, LB | Weequahic |
| Jabreil Salaam, OL | Columbia |
| CJ Ibezim, LB | Columbia |
| Ryan Cheesman, RB | Livingston |
| Alex Bauer, OT | Livingston |