2014 SEC All Conference Wrestling
American Division First Team
| Name | Weight | School |
| Robert Duxbury | 106 | Nutley |
| Isaiah Adams | 113 | West Orange |
| Joe Ferinde | 120 | Nutley |
| Tommy Heller | 126 | Livingston |
| Nick Russamanno | 132 | Caldwell |
| Anthony Canfora | 138 | Seton Hall |
| Jordan Velez | 145 | West Orange |
| Raymond Iodice | 152 | Caldwell |
| Joey Zarro | 160 | Livingston |
| Tom Grosso | 170 | Seton Hall |
| Christopher Morgan | 182 | West Orange |
| Marc McDonald | 195 | West Essex |
| Joe Galioto | 220 | Caldwell |
| Mark Dignazio | HWT | West Essex |
| Dean Caravela | open | Caldwell |
| Stephen Scuttaro | open | Nutley |
| Victor Lopez | open | West Orange |
| Anthony Ageday | open | West Orange |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Name | Weight | School |
| Nicholas Fierro | 106 | Seton Hall |
| Joe Pratola | 113 | Seton Hall |
| Aidan Monteverdi | 120 | Seton Hall |
| Christian Dalla Riva | 126 | Caldwell |
| Stanley Dameus | 132 | Bloomfield |
| Antonio Penna | 138 | West Orange |
| Ryan Condit | 145 | Caldwell |
| Alex Elliot | 152 | West Orange |
| Ryan Schaffer | 160 | Caldwell |
| Justin Corio | 170 | Bloomfield |
| Roberto LoCasio | 182 | West Essex |
| Joe Bongo | 195 | Caldwell |
| Matt Dignazio | 220 | West Essex |
| Ian Davidson | HWT | Caldwell |
| Chris Palmieri | open | Bloomfield |
| Ben Panza | open | Montclair |
| Darwin Pena | open | Nutley |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |
| Name | School |
| Kenny Pena | Nutley |
| Santino Gabriele | Nutley |
| Michael Galli | Bloomfield |
| Eduardo Millan | Bloomfield |
| Chris Zaccaria | West Essex |
| Jason Panico | West Essex |
| Kyle Man | Caldwell |
| Mario Pitch | Caldwell |
| Tyreer Staton | Montclair |
| Kris Diaz | Montclair |
| James Lax | Livingston |
| Mike Danenberg | Livingston |
| TJ Calas | Seton Hall |
| Justin Baker | Seton Hall |
| Daniel Okechuknu | West Orange |
| Kevin Guardado | West Orange |
LIBERTY DIVISION FIRST TEAM
| Name | Weight | School |
| Shawn Rooney | 106 | Cedar Grove |
| Joe Ballentyne | 113 | Verona |
| Dino Santiague | 120 | Irvington |
| Nehehima Shury | 126 | Irvington |
| Paul Sully | 132 | Verona |
| Nick Santorelli | 138 | Cedar Grove |
| Brandon Hayes | 145 | Columbia |
| Ryan Fearon | 152 | Cedar Grove |
| John Faugno | 160 | Glen Ridge |
| Mark Riggio | 170 | Verona |
| Cyriacus Ibezim | 182 | Columbia |
| Rob Sisciliano | 195 | Cedar Grove |
| Victor Rivera | 220 | Barringer |
| Garland Barham | HWT | Irvington |
| Jepthe Jean Paul | open | Irvington |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Name | Weight | School |
| Evander Jeanty | 106 | Irvington |
| Nyreek Loyal | 113 | Irvington |
| John Candela | 120 | Glen Ridge |
| Ryan Powers | 126 | Millburn |
| Patrick D’Egidio | 132 | Millburn |
| John Serruto | 138 | Millburn |
| Brian Wagner | 145 | Verona |
| Max Birner | 152 | Millburn |
| Jordan Greene | 160 | Belleville |
| Jerwin Martilus | 170 | Irvington |
| Tyhmir Lassiter | 182 | Irvington |
| Dyvenot Beaublanc | 195 | Irvington |
| Donchard Jean-Paul | 220 | Irvington |
| Jackson Miller | HWT | Columbia |
| Chris Barone | open | Cedar Grove |
| Matt Policarpio | open | Millburn |
| Nicolas Nardachone | open | Belleville |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |
| Name | School |
| Chris Bunay | Belleville |
| Ronald Smith | Belleville |
| Chris Virgadamo | Verona |
| Lou Mattia | Verona |
| RJ Serruto | Millburn |
| David Toradze | Millburn |
| Lorenzo Fazio | Cedar Grove |
| Mike Brown | Cedar Grove |
| Nasir WIlliams | Irvington |
| Jefferson Jean Paul | Irvington |
| Richie Ruiz | Barringer |
| Alex Cruz | Barringer |
| Declan Martins | Columbia |
| Columbia | |
| Jake Schwern | Glen Ridge |
| Anthony Santigate | Glen Ridge |
COLONIAL DIVISION FIRST TEAM
| Name | Weight | School |
| Anthony Santiago | 106 | Newark East Side |
| Keven Hernandez | 113 | Newark East Side |
| Xivandell Emmanuel | 120 | Orange |
| Eric Abney | 126 | Shabazz |
| Brendon Seyfried | 132 | Newark Academy |
| Von Isreal | 138 | Orange |
| Steve Bonsall | 145 | Newark Academy |
| Jyaire Atakora | 152 | Orange |
| Patrick Gerish | 160 | Newark Academy |
| Oziegbe Uhunmwangho | 170 | Weequahic |
| Ahmed Jones | 182 | Newark West Side |
| Ariel Salzar | 195 | Orange |
| Isaiah Miller | 220 | Newark West Side |
| Markel Pierre | HWT | Orange |
| Daniel Silva | open | Newark East Side |
| Bedy David | open | East Orange Campus |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Name | Weight | School |
| 106 | ||
| Altyrick Sherrod | 113 | Weequahic |
| Cormac Seyfried | 120 | Newark Academy |
| Jason Petit-Homme | 126 | Orange |
| Muhammad Hammuwd | 132 | East Orange |
| Dan Barahona | 138 | Newark East Side |
| Shaquan Pridgen | 145 | Orange |
| Nathaniel Tsimikas | 152 | Newark Academy |
| Michael Guest | 160 | Weequahic |
| 170 | ||
| Charlie Austin | 182 | Newark Academy |
| 195 | ||
| Dante Brunson | 220 | Orange |
| Jahe Williams | HWT | Weequahic |
| Elmer Fajardo | open | Orange |
| Randy Ross | open | Newark East Side |
| Wesley May | open | Shabazz |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |
| Name | School |
| Juvensin Etheard | Orange |
| Shaquan Chavis | East Orange |
| Michael Da Rocha | East Side |
| Kevin Harrison | Shabazz |
| Grady Henick | Newark Academy |
| Andre Chisulm | Weequahic |